30 September 2026
Grant dependency erodes accountability to citizens and cripples financial discipline
South Africa’s 257 municipalities are, in essence, publicly owned businesses. They hold a monopoly on essential services within their boundaries through electricity reticulation, water distribution, sewerage management and waste collection. They own the infrastructure, control the customer base, and levy tariffs for services rendered. They can also charge property rates on every rateable land parcel within their jurisdiction.
By any commercial standard this is an enviable market position: a captive customer base, essential products and multiple revenue streams. However, most municipalities are insolvent, dysfunctional and unable to maintain the assets that generate their income. The reason is not a lack of money. It is a failure to understand a municipality is a business.
A functional municipality should operate on a cost-reflective tariff model. Its trading services, namely water, electricity, sanitation and refuse, should generate sufficient revenue to cover operations, maintenance, debt service and a surplus for reinvestment. Property rates should fund the non-trading functions of governance, planning and community services.
This is the model the National Treasury is trying to enforce through the Metro Trading Services Reform, which ringfences water, electricity and waste revenues for reinvestment into infrastructure rather than diversion to salaries or political patronage. But for most municipalities this reform is too little, too late. They have already forgotten how to earn. The revenue leakage is staggering.
Municipalities collect, on average, only 40% to 70% of the revenue they bill. Of course there are exceptions to this, with a few municipalities collecting in the upper 90%. The rest disappears into nonpayment, illegal connections, broken billing systems and political cowardice.
No private sector business could survive a 30% revenue leak. Yet municipalities have persisted because they are propped up by the equitable share and conditional grants, transfers that anaesthetise them from commercial reality. When a municipality relies on grants rather than tariffs it ceases to be accountable to its customers and becomes accountable to the national fiscus. It optimises for grant compliance, not service quality.
The estimated R1.5-trillion national maintenance backlog is not merely a social services deficit. It is a balance sheet impairment
This perverts every decision. Instead of investing in infrastructure to expand the customer base and improve reliability, which would grow revenue, municipalities chase capital grants for new projects while allowing their income-generating assets to decay.
They build clinics without maintaining the sewage pump stations that keep them functional. They extend electricity networks without maintaining the substations that power them. They are the equivalent of a retailer spending all its capital on new shopfronts while letting its stockrooms flood and its supply chain break down.
The estimated R1.5-trillion national maintenance backlog is not merely a social services deficit. It is a balance sheet impairment. Every kilometre of water pipe, every electricity substation and every landfill cell is a capital asset. When municipalities fail to maintain them, they are writing down their own equity.
A business-minded asset manager understands routine maintenance preserves revenue streams. By contrast, municipalities spend only 4% of the R450bn value of their assets on upkeep. The result is predictable: roads that cost 18 times more to repair than to maintain, water plants that fail, and an infrastructure stock that is depreciating to zero.
If municipalities behaved as businesses, their priorities would invert. Revenue collection would be sacrosanct. They would invest in smart metering, automated billing and aggressive credit control because every rand uncollected is a rand that cannot fund infrastructure. They would cut off nonpayers, including government departments, because a business cannot survive on promises.
Maintenance would be treated as capital expenditure, not an afterthought. Feasibility studies would precede every project; no business builds a factory without a business case, yet municipalities routinely procure infrastructure without rigorous demand analysis or tariff modelling.
South Africa does not have an infrastructure problem. It has a revenue model problem disguised as an infrastructure problem
They would also leverage their balance sheets. A municipality with reliable revenue streams and well-maintained assets can borrow at favourable rates, issue municipal bonds or enter public-private partnerships where private capital brings expertise in exchange for a revenue share. But financiers do not lend to counterparties that cannot meter sales, collect debts or maintain their productive assets. This is why the R415bn in private sector investment pledges remains just that — pledges on paper.
The private sector will not invest until municipalities demonstrate creditworthiness. A business-minded municipality would also grow its customer base actively. It would plan for densification, industrial zoning and the formalisation of informal settlements because every new connection is a new revenue stream. Instead, many municipalities treat informal settlements as liabilities rather than as potential customers awaiting formalisation and metered supply.
The single greatest obstacle to this model is that municipalities are not run by business-minded officials. They are run by politicians whose time horizons are electoral cycles, not asset life cycles. A councillor gets more votes from opening a new facility than from repairing a sewage pump station, even though the pump station protects the municipality’s equity and the facility will fail without it. The business case and the political case are fatally misaligned.
South Africa does not have an infrastructure problem. It has a revenue model problem disguised as an infrastructure problem. Until municipalities remember they are in the business of selling services, not distributing grants, every budget, every investment conference and every manifesto promise will remain exactly what it is now: rhetoric without returns.
The framework of the law is sound, but it desperately needs the commercial instinct to make it work.
• Holeni is group chief adviser with management consulting firm Ntiyiso Consulting, specialising in local governance revenue management, governance and infrastructure. This is the first article in a series of four.
